InfiniBand vs Ethernet: A Technical Comparison for HPC and AI Compute Connectivity

In the rapidly evolving fields of high-performance computing (HPC) and artificial intelligence (AI), choosing the right interconnect for your compute nodes is critical. The two most prominent technologies—InfiniBand and Ethernet—have distinct strengths and are increasingly important for meeting the ultra-low-latency, high-throughput demands of modern computing. This blog will examine the performance of InfiniBand versus Ethernet in HPC and AI contexts, discuss how Ethernet is advancing to compete, and review the latest Cisco, Juniper, and Arista offerings in these areas. 

Performance Metrics: InfiniBand vs Ethernet 

InfiniBand: Leading in Low Latency and High Throughput 

InfiniBand has long been the preferred choice for HPC and AI applications, especially in environments where low latency and high bandwidth are critical. InfiniBand excels in the following areas: 

- Latency: Modern InfiniBand solutions, such as NVIDIA’s Quantum-2 InfiniBand, offer end-to-end latencies as low as 90 nanoseconds. This is significantly lower than most Ethernet solutions, making InfiniBand ideal for workloads like large-scale simulations, molecular dynamics, and AI model training that rely on tightly synchronized operations between nodes. 

- Throughput: InfiniBand currently supports bandwidths up to 400 Gbps, with advanced congestion control mechanisms like congestion-avoidance QoS that allow for minimal packet loss even under heavy loads. 

- RDMA (Remote Direct Memory Access): A major advantage of InfiniBand is RDMA, which allows direct memory-to-memory data transfers without CPU involvement, reducing overhead and accelerating communication between nodes. 

Ethernet: A Strong Contender in the Data Center 

Ethernet has traditionally been associated with enterprise networking, but recent developments have made it a viable option for HPC and AI. Converged Ethernet technologies are narrowing the performance gap with InfiniBand: 

- Latency: While Ethernet solutions have historically suffered from higher latencies, RDMA over Converged Ethernet (RoCE) has brought Ethernet latencies down significantly. With RoCEv2, latencies can reach as low as 1 to 2 microseconds, and innovations like Cisco’s Nexus 9000 series switches are helping Ethernet compete more aggressively. 

- Bandwidth: Ethernet is rapidly catching up in terms of throughput. 100G/400G Ethernet is common, and with advancements toward 800G Ethernet, Ethernet is becoming a competitive option for AI workloads. 

- Scalability: Ethernet’s primary strength lies in its widespread use and the ecosystem that supports it. The ability to scale Ethernet networks easily and integrate them into existing enterprise infrastructures is a major advantage for data centers. 

Cisco and Juniper: Pushing the Boundaries of Ethernet and InfiniBand 

Cisco’s Nexus 9000 series is at the forefront of converged Ethernet solutions. These switches are designed for 400G Ethernet and feature support for RoCEv2, which enables low-latency communication for HPC and AI workloads. The Cisco Nexus series is a go-to solution for organizations that want to build networks capable of competing with InfiniBand in terms of performance. 

- Latency: With features like cut-through switching and optimized buffer management, the Nexus 9000 series can achieve latencies around 1 microsecond, which is competitive for many AI applications. 

- Throughput: With support for 400G Ethernet, Cisco’s Nexus series delivers high throughput, making it suitable for data-intensive AI and machine learning tasks. 

Arista: Competing in the Ethernet Space 

Arista Networks has built its reputation on high-performance Ethernet switching, focusing on low-latency and high-throughput networking solutions. While Arista does not offer InfiniBand products, it has aggressively developed Ethernet solutions tailored for HPC and AI. 

Arista 7800R3 and 7500R3 Series 

Arista's 7800R3 and 7500R3 switches support 400G Ethernet and are designed for data centers running AI and machine learning workloads. They feature advanced telemetry, low-latency switching, and support for RoCEv2 for high-performance, low-latency data transfer. 

- Latency: Arista's cut-through architecture can deliver latencies as low as 400 to 600 nanoseconds in some configurations, which, while not as low as InfiniBand, is competitive for many data center workloads. 

- Scalability and Flexibility: With its EOS (Extensible Operating System) and support for 400G Ethernet, Arista offers high scalability and the flexibility to integrate into existing Ethernet-based data centers. 

Ethernet's Answer to InfiniBand: Converged Ethernet Standards 

Ethernet has made significant strides in closing the performance gap with InfiniBand through technologies like RoCE (RDMA over Converged Ethernet) and iWARP. These technologies allow Ethernet to provide RDMA capabilities, which are crucial for reducing latency and CPU overhead in HPC and AI applications. 

- RoCEv2: The second generation of RoCE improves upon the original by working over Layer 3 networks (IP-based), enabling it to scale better than the first version. RoCEv2 can bring Ethernet latencies down to 1 to 2 microseconds, much closer to InfiniBand. 

- Converged Ethernet (CE): Ethernet is also evolving through efforts like Converged Ethernet (CE), which incorporates advanced Quality of Service (QoS) mechanisms and congestion control to ensure predictable performance, similar to InfiniBand's strengths in deterministic networking. 

Can Ethernet Compete with InfiniBand? 

While InfiniBand continues to lead in ultra-low latency and high-throughput environments, Ethernet—particularly with RoCEv2 and 400G Ethernet—has become a formidable competitor in the HPC and AI space. As Ethernet evolves with technologies like 800G and improved latency handling, it may increasingly become the preferred choice for organizations looking to balance cost, performance, and scalability. 

Arista’s focus on high-performance Ethernet solutions, coupled with Cisco and Juniper’s converged Ethernet offerings, shows that Ethernet is rapidly evolving to meet the demands of AI and HPC workloads. While InfiniBand will likely remain the choice for ultra-low-latency applications, Ethernet's advancements—particularly in RoCE and cut-through switching—make it a strong contender for many data center environments.

At Terabit Systems, we remain committed to providing cutting-edge networking solutions tailored to our customers' needs. Call us at +1 (415) 230-4353 or click here to connect for a quote or to learn more.